A recent study suggests that one of the primary reasons American Christians do not give more generously is a lack of trust in the church.
If generosity is to flourish, trust must come first.
One of the most effective ways to build that trust is through clear, transparent church financial policies and practices. When congregations understand how money is handled, decisions are made, and accountability is maintained, they are more likely to give with confidence.
Effective policy builds trust—and trust creates the conditions where generosity can grow.
To help assess your congregation’s financial transparency and stewardship practices, here are thirty-six essential questions your church should be able to answer about money.¹
Financial Controls & Cash Handling
- Who is authorized to count money and record amounts?
- How are those persons chosen?
Donor Information & Confidentiality
- Who has access to information about donors?
- How are giving pattern changes reported and to whom?
- How often are constituents made aware of their record of giving?
Financial Reporting & Transparency
- Who (and how often) reports financial activity and who reviews/receives those reports?
- Are the reports transparent? (Available to all constituents and easy to read)
Budget Development & Governance
- Who builds the budget?
- How are those people chosen?
- Are they stake-holders in the outcome?
- Can any staff member vote on the personnel portion of the budget?
- How is the final budget adopted and by whom?
- Is the budget a target/estimate or is it “fixed in stone”?
- Is there a process for appeal or amendment to the budget and who can propose such action?
- Who responds to the request with final authority?
Staff Compensation & Evaluation
- What written policies are in place regarding salaries and benefits?
- How are they determined and how is staff evaluated? (Does job performance play a role in determining salary, and or benefit increases/decreases?)
- Is a COLA a part of the financial package and to what index is it tied?
Audits & Financial Accountability
- Are ALL accounts audited?
- How often and by whom?
- Who receives the audit report and what do they do with it?
Gifts Policy
- What policy is in place to receive bequests or other large undesignated gifts?
- Who decides how such a gift will be utilized in the church’s life and mission?
- Are people encouraged to make such gifts?
- What policy governs the receipt of real property gifts and or securities?
- What policy gives the church ultimate discretion as whether or not a gift will be accepted?
- With regard to gifts of a non-financial nature, is there a policy to govern the “retirement” of these gifts once they become no longer useable, worn out, or need replacement?
Investments, Reserves & Asset Management
- What policy governs the investment of monies in savings or reserves?
- Is there a limit to what can be held in reserve before other action is required?
Financial Decision-Making in Crisis
- If the organization is unable to meet all of its fiduciary responsibilities at any given time, who determines what bills get paid on time and what obligations do not get met?
Mission Alignment & Stewardship Priorities
- Does the church or organization reflect the principle of the tithe relative to mission beyond the local operating needs?
Closure & Legacy Planning
- If the church should become no longer financially viable, how are its assets to be distributed?
Risk Management & Insurance
- Does the church/organization have adequate insurance, especially against theft via fraud, fiduciary malfeasance, or embezzlement?
Leadership Development & Culture of Generosity
- Is every member of the governing body contributing at some level financially?
- What plan is in place for developing future leaders in this area?
- Are those who lead in the area of stewardship and finance leaders in giving?
These questions are not meant to overwhelm—they are meant to guide.
Each one is an opportunity to strengthen:
- Financial transparency
- Accountability
- Leadership integrity
- Donor confidence
And ultimately, they help cultivate a culture where generosity is not driven by obligation, but grounded in trust.
For more guidance and practical tools to address these questions, consult the Treasurer’s Handbook.
1Passing the Plate: Why American Christians Don’t Give Away More Money by Emerson and Smith. Oxford Press, New York, 2008.
