A Fresh Approach to Annual Stewardship
Every spring at our church, the annual stewardship campaign comes around. A faithful team of volunteers is tasked with what can feel like the impossible job of making each year’s campaign fresh and unique.
This was precisely the mission before us—the stewardship team—as we entered the 2023 campaign season.
A Spirit-Led Idea
Our stewardship team included both long-term members and newer participants. Each brought valuable perspective and contributed to the overall success of the campaign.
But one idea sparked a new level of enthusiasm:
“What if we take a page out of the PBS playbook and make matching donations part of this year’s campaign?”
At first, the idea felt uncertain. But as we sat with it, we sensed the Spirit nudging us to explore it more deeply.
We began asking important questions:
- How would matching contributions work in a church pledge campaign?
- Where would the matching funds come from?
Together, we developed a plan—and then we acted.
Securing Matching Gifts
The first step was to determine whether matching funds were possible.
Our pastor reached out to several of our most faithful contributors, shared the vision, and invited them to pledge additional matching dollars—above and beyond their existing commitments.
Within days, we had secured more than $10,000 in matching pledges from donors excited about inspiring first-time givers.
Launching the Campaign
With matching funds in place, we launched the campaign and centered this invitation in our messaging:
“If you’ve never pledged before, this is your opportunity to double the impact of your gift.”
The response was powerful.
People were eager to participate—not only in giving, but in joining the generosity already being modeled. We saw:
- New pledges from those who had never given before
- Increased participation from those who had given only occasionally
- Deep gratitude expressed toward those who made the match possible
The Results
By the end of the campaign:
- 18 first-time pledges (up from 6 the previous year)
- Approximately $17,000 in new pledges
- Matching funds exceeded
- $28,000 total increase in pledged contributions
For a church our size, this was significant.
But more important than the financial outcome was the sense of community and shared purpose that emerged. This creative, Spirit-led approach transformed the campaign into something more than a fundraiser—it became an experience of collective generosity.
It was good stewardship.
This idea was submitted by Rev. Melody Merida,the Senior Minister of Downey Avenue Christian Church (Disciples of Christ) in Indianapolis, IN.
