Giving long-term, appreciated publicly-traded stock is a tax-efficient way for members and friends to make gifts to their congregations or other ministries. These gifts are often larger than the typical cash gift and must be properly receipted by the church so that the donor has the required tax return support.
While receiving gifts of stock involves additional steps on the part of the receiving ministry, the ability to make stock gifts allows donors to make larger, more tax-efficient gifts. This guide will help your congregation understand how to receive and receipt stock gifts.
Overview
In order to preserve the tax benefits of stock gifts, the ministry receiving the gift must receive the actual stock—not just the cash realized from the sale of the stock.
- Stock owned for less than one year (short-term stock) will not receive favorable tax treatment and should not be used for charitable giving.
- Stock purchased for more than its current value will generate a tax loss and is better sold by the owner.
- Only stock held for more than one year and valued above its purchase price (“long-term appreciated stock”) should be used for charitable giving.
Understanding the Benefits of Gifting Long-Term Appreciated Stock
Ruth pledges $20,000 each year to her congregation. She currently holds $24,000 of Apple stock that she purchased for $4,000.
If Ruth sells the stock:
- She will pay capital gains tax on her $20,000 gain
- At a 15% rate, she pays $3,000 in federal tax
- With a 5% state tax, she pays an additional $1,000
After taxes, Ruth has $20,000 left to give.
If Ruth instead gifts the stock:
- The “cost” to her is the same
- The church receives $24,000 (20% more)
Alternatively, she could gift $20,000 in stock and retain $4,000 for future giving.
Gifts of stock enhance a donor’s ability to be generous.
How to Receive a Stock Gift
To receive gifts of stock, ministries must first establish a brokerage account in the name of the ministry.
- Discount brokers (such as Charles Schwab or TD Ameritrade) are often the most cost-efficient option
- The account must be in the name of the charity to preserve tax advantages
- Donors should transfer stock directly into the ministry’s brokerage account
- The stock should be sold promptly within the charity’s account
As with any financial account, someone independent of the Treasurer or Financial Secretary should regularly review transactions for appropriateness.
How to Receipt a Stock Gift
It may be tempting to record the sale amount of the stock as the donor’s contribution—don’t fall into this trap. Stock gifts require special written receipting.
Your acknowledgment should include:
1. Date of the Gift
If received electronically, the gift date is the date the stock arrives in your brokerage account. (This date is critical for determining the donor’s deduction.)
2. Description of the Gift
Describe the stock received. For example: “Received 220 shares of Apple, Inc. (NASDAQ: AAPL) in our brokerage account on December 20, 2016.”
3. Statement Regarding Goods or Services
For any gift over $250 (cash or stock), the acknowledgment must state whether goods or services were received. If none were provided, include:
“No goods or services, other than intangible religious benefits, were received.”
Without this statement, the gift will not be deductible by the donor.
(See IRS Publication 526 for more information.)
4. Expression of Thanks
Always include a sincere thank-you on behalf of your ministry
5. Valuation Information
The deductible value of publicly traded stock is based on the average of the high and low market price on the date of the gift.
For documentation:
- Do not include a dollar amount on the receipt
- Do provide:
- Stock name
- Number of shares
- Date received
If desired, you may include a separate sheet with high/low values and calculated estimates—but this is not required.
We recommend:
- Not confusing the sale amount with the donor’s deductible value
- Issuing stock gift receipts separately from cash giving statements
- Selling stock promptly upon receipt
A final word:
We are all called to be good stewards of the gifts entrusted to us. Being willing and able to receive a gift of long-term, appreciated, publicly-traded stock is a great way to help your members and friends to be better stewards of their resources.
Note: In addition to publicly-traded stock, donors may also hold stock in small, family-owned, or “thinly-traded” companies. Gifts of this type of stock are possible, but require expertise that is outside the scope of this article. See IRS Publication 561 for more information on how to value donated property.
