When Volunteers Aren’t Enough
For generations, congregations have relied on faithful volunteers to keep the books, pay the bills, prepare financial reports, and handle countless other financial responsibilities.
But what happens when those volunteers are ready to step away—or when the work requires more time, capacity, or expertise than your congregation has available?
Hiring a bookkeeper may be one way to build a more sustainable financial system. This guide, created in partnership with Epiphany Bookkeeping, LLC will help your congregation take an honest look at your current practices, consider whether outside bookkeeping makes sense, and know what to look for if you decide it’s time to hire.
Start with the Right Question
Is Your Current System Sustainable?
Before asking “Who should we hire?” take a closer look at how your congregation handles its finances now.
Do you have skilled volunteers willing to manage bookkeeping, payroll, reconciliations, financial reports, and other responsibilities? More importantly, if one of those people stepped away tomorrow, does someone else have the knowledge and capacity to take over?
The guide will help you consider:
- Your current financial leadership and volunteer capacity
- How your present financial system developed
- Whether responsibilities have accumulated simply because “that’s how we’ve always done it”
- How much time and expertise your current system requires
- Whether outside bookkeeping could strengthen continuity and accountability
Consider What You Actually Need
A Bookkeeper Doesn’t Have to Do Everything
Hiring outside help doesn’t mean handing over your congregation’s entire financial operation.
A bookkeeper might handle specific responsibilities such as entering deposits, paying bills, categorizing income and expenses, completing reconciliations, preparing reports, or producing contribution statements. Moving some of those tasks outside the congregation may also make it possible for volunteers to serve in financial leadership roles without needing extensive accounting expertise.
The goal isn’t simply to fill a position. It’s to build a financial system your congregation can sustain.
If You’re Ready to Hire
Know What to Ask
Experience matters—especially when it comes to church finances.
The guide includes practical questions to ask prospective bookkeepers about their experience with congregations, familiarity with your accounting platform, references, onboarding process, monthly reporting schedule, communication, and backup plans when they are unavailable.
It also helps you think through practical considerations such as cost and whether an in-person or virtual bookkeeping relationship makes the most sense for your congregation.
Hiring Help Doesn’t Mean Giving Up Oversight
Even when bookkeeping is outsourced, responsibility for the congregation’s finances remains with congregational leadership.
Continue reviewing bank and financial statements, maintain approval controls for payments, limit access to bank accounts appropriately, and conduct periodic financial reviews.
Outsource the work—not the accountability.
Ready to Take a Closer Look?
Use Is It Time to Hire a Bookkeeper? with your pastor, treasurer, finance team, or board to evaluate your current financial system and begin a conversation about what your congregation needs for the future.
